Film, TV, DVD
YOU ARE HERE: Home » Film, TV, DVD » TV Overdose » Comedy Going Stale
Comedy Going Stale
Comedy Going Stale

Comedy Going Stale

Can't we let classics become classic? Bloody repeats

It is said that the true test of a comedy program is the test of time. Will it still be discussed in 20 years? Will youngsters who donned nappies in that show’s heyday discover it and enjoy the laughs?

Those classics that have stood the test of time include Fawlty TowersBlackadder, Python. Sod it even Partridge and Mr Bean.

More recently we’ve half-enjoyed cringing at The Office and Extras but with the deluge of channels and comedic output around now, fewer shows will elevate to classic status, burdened as many are by the decision-making skills of acne riddled schedulers. Those bloody repeats.

Most classics would repeat at a later time – why discount the opportunity to bring in the ratings again? But now it seems as soon as it’s over, it’s back on the box.

Channel 4 recently announced that as of 2011, Friends will be off the air and considering there hasn’t been a new episode in five years I welcome the decision.

Friends 300x186 Comedy Going Stale

I need a break. I enjoy – or should that be past tense – enjoyed Friends, but after six episodes a day, every day it grows older, more clichéd and starts to grate at your eyes and hum at your soul – Smelly Cat, Smelly Cat…

Like a cake left out in the open air, once so delightful, tasty and fresh, everything’s gone stale and flat. How can it stand the test of time when it’s never off the bloody air?

Mock the Week is in a similar state of dis-repeat – like Friends it’s never off.

It’s even on two channels now with Dave buying repeats on top of those reshown on BBC2. It makes the head spin – I can’t tell what’s new and what’s old so if you’re listening acne riddled decision makers, give  the maybe-classics (and your skin) some time to breathe.

mock the week 299x300 Comedy Going Stale

Panel shows rarely stand the test of time as they’re generally topical so I’ll breathe a welcome sigh of relief if the Beeb pulls the plug on Mock.

Not to shatter the illusion but we know the show is scripted and made up of rehashed outtakes from the performers stand-up shows, don’t we?

3 Comments

Ed Bemand
Ed Bemand

There’s something profoundly wrong about the endless repeats of topical quizzes that seems to make up the brunt of Dave’s non Top Gear broadcasting. I’m sure it is very cheap for them, but do they have to show so much of it??

Glen

Don’t take this idea too far.
Mock the week is a very funny programme and is only ruined by it’s incessant repeats. Calling for the show to be pulled is a terrible idea, and will rob viewers of one of the few shows worth turning on your TV on for. Repeats are the problem. Not the shows.

Friends? Couldn’t agree more. It should have died so many times already, but still it dawdles, decaying humour everywhere.

under_score

The problem is not comedy gone stale: watch something endlessly and you’ll get bored of it whatever it is. The problem in fact is the proliferation of digital channels. If you have a channel dedicated to a particular audience but you only actually make Hollyoaks and Skins to cater for them, you have to fill it with enjoyable, anodyne favourites. In fact, Friends lasted so long because it isn’t stale – it may be fluff, but watch an episode in isolation, it’s so tightly written it squeaks. Think about it, it’s 7.30pm, the One Show has just lamentably finished, you can either watch rolling news or some BBC2 documentary about a vicar in the Shetlands or something. You’re going to watch Friends.

That’s not to say that comedy isn’t getting stale, but repeats are not the cause of this, they’re an effect: new comedy is bloody awful. Watch anything, I mean anything, on BBC3. Staler than a loaf from Costcutter.

Leave a Reply




Subscribe without commenting